Entertainment Weekly recently revealed its selections for the 100 best characters (from apparently any form of fictional entertainment) of the last 20 years.

Some of these were vibrantly appropriate, life-affirming choices (e.g., G.O.B. Bluth, Tracy Flick, Corky St. Clair). And some, of course, were preposterous pigslop (e.g., Vivian Ward, Shrek . . . Maximus? Really, guys?).
Still, I had fun reading through them, and I inevitably found myself mulling those whose exclusion outraged me. And then I thought, Say, I have a blog . . . I can make my own danged list.
Suckaz.
Here are 15 characters I feel are worthy of “best” status. To be a good sport, I shall stick to EW‘s time line: the last 20 years. Sadly, that means no Nigel Tufnel, no Owen Meany, no Wembley Fraggle, no Old Man Parker, no Edmund Blackadder, no Alex. . . . ) No problem.
———————————————————————————
1) Max Fischer
Truly a goldmine. Such complexity, yet such subtlety! Such love! Such hate! The piranhas! The bees! It took plenty, I’m sure, simply to conceive of someone like Max. To write for him was a whole other level of uncharted brilliance. And Jason Schwartzman’s finishing twitches are what make the young man legend.
Max can handle being left off the EW list, though. He wrote a hit play and directed it, so he’s not sweating it either.
2) Arturo “Arty” Binewski
I knew virtually nothing about Katherine Dunn’s Geek Love when I bit it off, so to speak, and I was thoroughly slapped around by the experience (in a good way, inasmuch as that’s possible). For that, I have Arty to thank. No small feat to design a character with no arms or legs and turn him into a sinister, disturbing, Machiavellian force of nature. The tenets of his cult of Arturism alone rocket this flipper-baby onto my list.
3) Montana Moorehead
Celeste Talbert is a menopausal hag. Let’s see more of Montana Moorehead!
Speaking of Machiavellian. This one just makes the cut, chronologically, and phew! Where would we be without this sugarplum? I know where Jeffrey Anderson would be — he’d be playing Willy Loman in front of old farts eating meat loaf! Chewing and slurping and spitting out their pits! Only through her unique brand of shrill sticktoitness can Montana move mountains and bring folks together. Frankly, I don’t understand why Cathy Moriarty hasn’t been cast in everything since this movie came out.
4) Benjamin Linus
John Locke got the EW nod, as you may have noticed in the image above. And while I in no way impugn his introspective journey, nor Terry O’Quinn’s elegance in portraying it, I’ve got to award the match to Ben when all is said and done.
(And, as of last month, it is.)
5) Sean Connery (SNL Celebrity Jeopardy incarnation)
The day is his!
6) Sara Goldfarb
Anyone who can watch Requiem for a Dream without feeling an overwhelming urge to call his or her mother is just . . . well, you must have a heart of titanium, my friend. All the way around, this is a stunning adaptation of Hubert Selby’s already stunning novel. More to the point, though, witnessing Ellen Burstyn’s disintegration in this film is one of the most torturous cinematic experiences I’ve ever had — but ’tis such a beauteous torture, a glorious agony, to shield our eyes against the feeble seeping of Sara’s dignity and maternity. It is, to this day, a major pebble in my shoe that Ms. Burstyn did not receive the Oscar that year.
7) Patrick Bateman
I’m rather amazed, I must say, that EW bypassed this one. Too controversial, perhaps? I am thinking particularly of the literary incarnation, of which the onscreen Patrick is a mere shadow. Page after page of obsessive, narcissistic psychopathy, punctuated by ruthlessly detailed product inventories, restaurant reviews, and the occasional doctoral dissertation on an ’80s pop legend. Or human slaughter. That, sir, is a memorable persona.
8) Mary
Some of my movie-buff friends may not agree. But I have long found the diminutive focal point of Party Girl to be fairly transfixing. She’s just so . . . all over the place, in a way that I doubt was fully mandated by the screenplay itself. Hence my mild hero worship of/girl-crush on Parker Posey. I forgive you, Parker, for You’ve Got Mail. I do. Let’s just learn from it and move on.
9) Walter Sobchak
EW gave it to The Dude, and I’d be the last person to disagree. But Walter is just too good not to get his own back-pat.
10) Suzanne Stone Maretto
My opinions of Nicole Kidman have swung dramatically over the years. I think she’s very good, yet for some reason, I often don’t enjoy watching her in things. Clearly this is my issue, not hers, and she should not trouble herself with it. But I abso-tively enjoy watching her in To Die For, a delightful treat that far too few people have embraced. Personally, I think the problem is the unfortunate combination of the title and the artwork, which are in cahoots to make this look like a cheesy, formulaic Basic Instinct replica. Not so, I say! This movie has a lot of genius to it, and an outstanding cast . . . and Kidman just plain owns her sensational role.
(A quiet shout-out to Joaquin’s Jimmy Emmett — also a deeply memorable character.)
11) Bret and Jemaine
Don’t get huffy; the EW list had some multiperson entries (Mulder and Scully, for example).
I came close to handing this one to Murray Hewitt, in honor of his perpetual, raised-eyebrows earnestness, but it seemed wrong not to recognize the show’s more iconic elements. I’m not claiming that the lovable idiot has never been done before, nor that it has never been done in a pairs format. But so many things work in this particular pair’s favor: the accents, the fish-out-of-waterness, their invariably mild delivery, their gentle tolerance of Mel, the sideburns, the animal sweatshirts, and — most important — the music. It gives these two the opportunity to “come at” their characters in as many ways as they like. The more they step out of character in the songs, the more they reinforce their characters in the not-songs. There. Meditate on that one for a while.
12) Kirk Lazarus
There’s nothing about this individual or Robert Downey, Jr.’s portrayal of him that isn’t freaking brilliant. The fact that Justin Theroux played a part in bringing Kirk to life just makes me love him more; I’ve had a thing for Theroux since Mulholland Dr. I’m not surprised Downey did not get the Oscar (can you imagine the uproar if Heath had lost out to someone in Tropic Thunder, for crying out loud?), but it made for a nice little pipe dream that he was nominated.
13) Piscine “Pi” Patel
Another one I’m surprised EW skipped, given the sensation that Yann Martel’s book caused at its release. But it’s been a while since I’ve found a character who was so intellectually engrossing. Damn the cliché of loving this book — I loved this book! And I loved Pi himself, and I rooted for him unconditionally.
14) Shelley Levene
I’d wager that Glengarry Glen Ross is not for everyone (real estate sales don’t really constitute that summer-blockbuster premise, if that’s your thing). But it is for me, and the hapless Shelley was just a joy to pity. Pacino’s Ricky Roma definitely gave me the biggest hoot, but he lacked Shel’s tortured complexity, his layers of despair. O Jack Lemmon, we miss thee.
15) Lucille Bluth
Believe me, I am grateful for Gob’s inclusion in the EW list. In no respect do I pooh-pooh that. But at the end of the day (my brother will be so annoyed with me for using that phrase), Lucille is my inspiration. She is a virtuoso of character composition! She is the Seaward! She’s thirsty! She’s in rehab! She doesn’t care for Gob! She baited the balcony! She has a rape horn! She gets off on being withholding! She doesn’t know what Jimmy Kimmel Live is, nor does she care to find out! You can find her in the hospital bar!